Let's throw out the rulebooks

Friday, 28 November 2008 19:23 by Sreejay S
The horror in Mumbai is winding down as I write this. Over the last 50 hours or so, I have been following it on TV as well as online for my own coverage of it on this site.

Some of you may remember my earlier (maligned) post on Indian nationality. Sadly, we can see that it turns out to be too accurate if not very likeable.

The truth of the matter is, we have lost sight of what is great about this nation of ours, of the immensity, the diversity and the ultimate unity of our people, born and raised in the same culture.

If we do not yet learn, in this hour of tragedy, to come together as a nation, we never will.

For decades, ever since the Independence, we have been fractured by the megalomania of small groups of people, who call themselves our leaders. Let us for one moment, on this day, recommit ourselves to say, "ENOUGH".

I heard on TV that Mrs. Karkare, the widow of the ATS chief killed in the Mumbai terror attacks, had refused to meet the Gujarat CM, Mr. Modi, who had earlier announced a huge sum of money to the families of officers killed in the action.

Good on her, I say. Imagine the sheer chutzpah of the politician in Mr. Modi, to take this tragic moment to score Brownie points – and remember, he was someone who was breathing fire at this same officer for the arrest of the Hindu terror suspects.

I used the words ‘Hindu’ and ‘Terror’ in conjunction deliberately.

I do not believe that terror has a religion. It is neither Islamic nor Hindu.

If the persons arrested in connection with the Malegaon blasts are responsible, they are, simply put, terrorists. They are definitely not Hindus. For they do not understand the spirit of the 5000 years of Hindu culture. They do not understand the multiplicity of gods and the complexity of the message of Hinduism.

And the same holds for these terrorists who claim to fight in Allah’s cause. There is no place in the Koran (I assure you, I have read it) that says anything about harming innocents. Jihad is about protecting the believers (in God, not of religion) against aggressors, like the Prophet did from the attackers from Mina and Medina.

But, I digress.

I do not wish to argue religion. I wish to discuss morality and nationalism (in the true sense) and humanity above all.

Let us first tell these ‘people’s representatives’ as they call themselves that it is time to really lead. Tell them that their pettiness (which is immeasurable) has run its course. Tell them that peace is not an option – it is a state of life.

Second, do not blame Pakistan immediately. Yes, blame the involvement of Pakistanis in it – but not Pakistan, the nation, or its people. They are more ‘sinned against than sinning’. Let us give the largely democratic government there a chance to help – listen, before you condemn.

Third, let us see why we have an environment of resentment among the communities – Hindu, Muslim, Christian or North Indian, South Indian, Marathis, Tamils… Let us relearn to be Indians.

Finally, and most importantly, let us throw away the rulebooks for engaging terrorists. Here, I will contradict some of what I said earlier – forgive me. The issue is, we cannot mitigate the cause of a fire before it is put out. So, let us give our police and armed forces independence from the corrosive influence of politics to do their job, and do their job forcefully. Let us not cavil at possible hairs ruffled or a few innocents caught up. Reparations can be made later. Immediate action is more important.

I saw a lot of hate on the comments written by people on this site on various issues. Especially, the Mumbai issue and the Lanka Tamil issue. Many are bigoted, jingoistic and warmongering. These are little people – people who have little minds. India is above that – far, far better. Let us not let our land fall into the hands of these people by sheer inaction, saying, “But, I am safe.”

Remember, we tread on the footsteps of a nation of people who were able to come together across divides of history, region, language and culture. Let us not fall prey to these terrorists who have attacked us from outside humanity. At the same time, let us beware of those in our midst who attack us with divisions of language and region, trying to grab and hold on to what little power and wealth they can filch – look around, they are among you.

Currently rated 3.0 by 22 people

  • Currently 2.954545/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Comments

November 27. 2008 09:17

Sivakumar

Good

Sivakumar

November 27. 2008 15:12

anu

r u a foolish mulsim terrorist

anu

November 27. 2008 17:07

Sreejay S

Interesting response, Anu. No - I am an Indian, if you understand what that really means. And no, I am a Hindu, practising, and believing - but also, as a true Hindu, tolerant.

And thanks, Sivakumar.

Sreejay S

November 27. 2008 18:38

infidel

You have read Quran, haven't you?

And you say "There is no place in the Koran (I assure you, I have read it) that says anything about harming innocents."

That is a real laugh. Quran is obsessed with believers and non-believers. In fact, most of quran is about how to deal with non-believers. If you want, can I send you a real authentic version of Quran?

By the way, you sure know what Al-Taqiyya means, you are a good proponent of this!

infidel

November 28. 2008 02:42

Sreejay S

Infidel - nice use of a pseudonym. An unbeliever...

Al-Taqiyya? I am not hiding what I believe in - I am not afraid to say what I believe in, and that is my Indianness. How about you?

Sreejay S

November 28. 2008 21:22

anu

what is hindu tolerance ??

Islam represents people who bite the hand that feeds them

anu

November 29. 2008 00:40

Ghosh

India was attacked by foreign forces(Ghazini, Ghauri et al) in the 13th century, which later ruled over India, by Mughals. Prez Musharaff,when he took over the dictatorship, spoke from the Lahore Fort that the British erred in handing over the control to Honourable Gandhi(people of your ilk)and it would have been appropriate that Jinnah ruled over India. Had that been a reality, you would have been a Muslim(by conversion).

Thanks

Ghosh

November 29. 2008 01:52

Sreejay S

Anu, It is not 'Hindu Tolerance'! Hinduism is about tolerance itself - we absorb everything that comes to us and we assimilate them such that there is no differentiation. Look at our 33 crore gods, all of which is part of the one whole... A beautiful concept, is it not?

And you, nameless commenter, I talk about what is, and what must be - not what could have been and what could be. I just have pity for you... If you cannot understand Gandhi, you cannot understand India.

Sreejay S

November 30. 2008 05:49

anu

You journalists dont know anything abt teror, just write stories and say we should be tolerant to this mulsim dogs,

but what will you do if your house burns and you feel very insecure to go out in broad daylight.

this is not the time to be tolerant but to take strict action against terrorists show them what INDIA CAN DO to them and their country porkisthan

anu

November 30. 2008 17:02

Sreejay S

Anu, I am sure there are, at the moment at least, many like you who would like that.

Burning houses? Insecurity?
Don't be silly - these have always been there. The reality is, no ONE community or religion is to blame. Megalomania is common to all - and it is the megalomania of a few in all societies that create grief. Lenin said it (in a different context)- "The purpose of terror is to terrorise". Nothing more

I do not judge on generalities. Not because I am a journalist - but because I am a Human Being - more to the point, an Indian

Sreejay S

December 1. 2008 01:17

sanjay

I have been reading this blog and comments for quiet some time and found that the author is speaking parellel to the sacked politiican from mumbai patil

>>>Burning houses? Insecurity?
>>>>>Don't be silly - these have always been there.

patil also said something like this and he was thrown out mr. sreejoy

you are a shame to India

sanjay

December 1. 2008 01:20

sanjay

And Anu you are one brave girl from India,

All youth like you and me unite and save this country, some old sags like this author will still preach tolerance till their **** i dont want to tell it

until a muslim terrorist puts a gun near his head these people wont bother

sanjay

December 1. 2008 05:00

Sreejay S

Sanjay
If you really have been reading the post and comments, I see no reason for any further explanation on my part. Strangely, your email id seems to include the name 'Gandhi'

One little observation though, when I was going through an arms training programme, there was this friend of mine, who was so gung-ho about firing the Sten gun. He was posing like Rambo with it and making tak-tak-tak noises, much to our instructors' amusement. We got to the firing range, and at the first shot, he almost killed the instructor and wet his pants! He has not touched a gun since then...

Just saying... Smile

Sreejay S

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)  

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



click here